Not to get too magical-mystical here, but when we're talking about the FISA Court and USA PATRIOT Act and the shenanigans at NSA and the FBI, etc - I think I have to go along with Mark Udall; mostly anyway - and Obama too btw. There has to be a balance, which (imo) we've let get away from us in a pretty big way.
Balance is kinda the key to the whole self-governance thingie. We have to continue to develop better ways to catch the bad guys after the fact - and better yet, prevent the bad guys from doin' the dirt in the first place - without making it more probable that some tin-plated martinet will abuse the power, and turn it to his own ends. (Thank you, Capt Obvious)
Here's 5 minutes of Udall on NPR, talking about what he and Ron Wyden are proposing:
Almost at the very end, Udall makes a point that kinda blew up in my brain. He said (paraphrasing), "...privacy is the ultimate form of freedom".
If I make a not-entirely-silly leap, I can say Privacy = Anonymity; and in a still not-so-silly way, Anonymity = Invisibility; and Invisibility is very much the be-all and end-all of the super powers.
On the one hand, if nobody can see you, then nobody can fuck with you. This is mostly a very good thing for individuals.
But on the other hand, if you can't be seen, then you can't be held to account for anything you do. This is always a very bad thing for societies.
So, balance. Aye, there's the rub.
hat tip = Little Green Footballs
Balance is kinda the key to the whole self-governance thingie. We have to continue to develop better ways to catch the bad guys after the fact - and better yet, prevent the bad guys from doin' the dirt in the first place - without making it more probable that some tin-plated martinet will abuse the power, and turn it to his own ends. (Thank you, Capt Obvious)
Here's 5 minutes of Udall on NPR, talking about what he and Ron Wyden are proposing:
Almost at the very end, Udall makes a point that kinda blew up in my brain. He said (paraphrasing), "...privacy is the ultimate form of freedom".
If I make a not-entirely-silly leap, I can say Privacy = Anonymity; and in a still not-so-silly way, Anonymity = Invisibility; and Invisibility is very much the be-all and end-all of the super powers.
On the one hand, if nobody can see you, then nobody can fuck with you. This is mostly a very good thing for individuals.
But on the other hand, if you can't be seen, then you can't be held to account for anything you do. This is always a very bad thing for societies.
So, balance. Aye, there's the rub.
hat tip = Little Green Footballs
No comments:
Post a Comment